Bitcoin vs. Stocks: Comparing Price Movements and Traits

Bitcoin’s meteoric rise over the past decade has put traders in mainstream markets on notice. It’s easy to draw comparisons between BTC’s stellar performance versus traditional stock indexes.

Oftentimes, given crypto’s reputation of being an “evolution” of money, we see widespread comparisons of crypto to fiat, such as Bitcoin being compared to assets such as the U.S. dollar and gold.  Plus, many traders think of their gains and losses in fiat terms. 

However, when it comes to market movements, Bitcoin more closely resembles traditional stocks. Before Bitcoin’s rise, the stock market had been the platform of choice for people who want to grow their asset portfolios . So understandably, when Bitcoin emerged as a fast-rising substitute with comparable potential and volatility, the conversation shifted towards cryptocurrencies.

Let’s compare Bitcoin’s year-to-date performance over the S&P 500 (an index that reflects the stock performance of 500 top U.S. companies), or the NASDAQ 100 (an index tracking the 100 top U.S. companies).

Source: TradingView

Based on the chart above, your $1,000 invested in Bitcoin (BTC) at the start of 2020 would have grown to $1,660 (shown in orange), compared to $1,265 if you chose NASDAQ (shown in red) or just $1,029 for S&P 500 (shown in blue). Of course, prices fluctuate on a day-to-day basis, but this is just one of the many instances that show Bitcoin’s competitiveness as an asset class.

The results are similar for blue-chip stocks. In 2017, when Bitcoin’s rally entered the public’s consciousness, stock analysts classified five tech companies as standard-bearers for blue-chip stock. These companies — Facebook Inc. (FB), Apple Inc. (AAPL), Inc. (AMZN), Netflix Inc. (NFLX), and Alphabet Inc.’s Google (GOOGL), exhibited great performances in the stock market in the recent decade. 

Let’s compare these FAANG stocks to Bitcoin and two other popular cryptocurrencies: Ethereum (ETH) and BNB. 

Asset / StockYear-to-date Growth$ Gain from $1,000 investment on Jan 1
Bitcoin (BTC) 66.02%$660.20
Ethereum (ETH)204.41%$1,041.10
BNB (BNB)65.19%$651.90
Facebook (FB)23.89%$238.90
Apple (AAPL)50.50%$505.00
Amazon (AMZN)66.61%$666.10
Netflix (NFLX)44.16%$441.60
Google (GOOGL)10.12%$101.20

This table shows that in 2020 alone, crypto can stand head to head against some of the best blue-chip stocks on the market.

Comparing Bitcoin to Stocks

In a previous article, we did a side-by-side comparison between Bitcoin and gold. This time, let’s extend this comparison to stocks so that we can better understand the pros and cons of the two asset classes.

ScarcityIs the asset scarce? Is the supply limited?Yes (21 million BTC maximum guaranteed.)Depends (Companies can always issue more stock.)
Counterfeit ResistanceIs the asset hard or impossible to fake?Yes (It is independently verifiable via blockchain.)Yes, but… (Stocks are verified by companies, but may require auditing.)
PortabilityCan you use or transfer the asset anywhere?Yes (Can be used to pay or to transfer value anywhere in the world.)Not quite (Generally can’t use stocks outside of the stock market.)
DecentralizationIs this asset independent in a way that no central authority controls it?Yes (Creating and governing it involves a network of decentralized nodes or computers.)No (All stocks come from just one company, and are usually held by a few controlling shareholders.)
DivisibilityCan one unit of this asset be divided into smaller quantities?Yes (There are 100,000,000 satoshis in one bitcoin.)Sometimes (Generally not divisible, unless a company engages in a stock split.)
DurabilityIs this asset protected in the long-term?Yes (As a digital asset, Bitcoin won’t deteriorate.)Depends (Stocks are reliant on a company’s longevity.)
FungibilityCan this asset be traded for other goods or assets?Yes (You can use Bitcoin to pay for other asset classes, as well as a wide array of goods.)Yes to a limited extent (You can cash in or cash out, or you may enter certain deals, but you don’t usually use stocks to pay for goods on a whim.)
User-friendliness and AwarenessIs the asset easy to use? Is it known to more people?Not quite yet (Though awareness is increasing, Bitcoin has a long way to go in terms of general knowledge. Given its 10-year history, this is understandable.)Not quite (Just a tiny fraction of the world’s population deal with stocks, despite its centuries-old existence as an asset class.)

We should also point out that you can earn Bitcoin without having to buy it in the market, by participating in a bitcoin mining pool like Binance Pool. he only way you can get additional stocks in a company is if they initiate a stock split on your holdings. And while Bitcoin doesn’t have a system similar to stock dividends on certain companies, other cryptocurrencies have introduced staking mechanisms where holders of certain tokens can earn additional crypto. 

Regardless of how you decide to diversify your assets, considering Bitcoin as an option doesn’t hurt, if at least to be aware of this digital asset as an option for you. After all, previous studies have shown that portfolios containing Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies generally outperform crypto-free portfolios. And if you decide to add Bitcoin to your portfolio, Binance is here to give you a convenient experience when it comes to buying your first Bitcoin.

* All figures were as of August 13, 7 AM UTC.